In the US, everybody expects a minimum 25 bps cut if not 50 bps. Canada started cutting early, perhaps being the first G7 to cut. He's not sure if we'll keep suit, but we have cover now to keep going along with the US.
It puts them in a bit of a bind with where we are in the economic picture right now. Some things are softening and supporting expectations of rate cuts, but we're also seeing some inflationary pressures start to build again. The Fed is notoriously late on things, but he thinks Powell is trying to be prudent right now. Thinks the Fed would rather wait, but the clarion sound is so shrill right now, they feel they have to cut.
This all started right after the US election with the threat of tariffs coming. Then early in February, he was looking at the futures, particularly the FX, and the CAD was just getting crushed. The CAD went on to recover.
With the tariff announcements, the prognostications were that we'd be in big trouble. That whole narrative got unwound. So all those people who were worried about it are coming in late to the market. If we look at the structure of the market right now, this is not the best time. Lots of technicals signalling caution -- September/October is historically weak, some indicators are at overbought.
This piling in is missing out on some of the returns we've seen since April and is trying to push in at the last minute.
That said, there's some sort of corrective environment in the offing. Whatever the nature of it is or how long, it's going to be bid at the lows and right after that.
After 30 years in the business, there are some areas he just avoids because they never seem to make money. Transportation is one, with too many variables that make a positive return challenging. Airlines. Car makers, though modern car makers like TSLA and RIVN are a different kettle of fish, as they're changing the structure of the business.
There is a relationship between the commodity and the producers of commodity. Commodities and producers should go in the same direction. But it's always the producers that lead, because they're the smart people who know what's going on with that commodity, whether gold or oil.
If producers are high and then start to roll over, but the commodity stays high, then you can bet the commodity will eventually roll over. And vice versa.
Sometimes it's like the advice you get from your mom or your grandma, like put your coat on. Use common sense principles. You've done really well on a stock, so what are you waiting for? If a stock's grown so big in your portfolio, and you're trying to time when to do it, just the fact that you're asking the question means it's probably the moment.
It comes down to portfolio management, rather than a fundamental or technical analysis.
Generally, a confirming indicator. So when you get a lot of volume but you have bad news, and it holds, that's positive. If you break down on a lot of volume, and there's no place it holds but keeps going down, then that's a negatively confirming indicator. Or if you break out of a congestion area with a lot of volume, it means you have a lot of commitment.
So it's quite imporant.
Very prone to geopolitical stuff. US is pushing hard on India to get them to stop buying Russian oil.
It's been kind of lumpy. So producers don't go out and look for new mines or wells. Any bit of upside out of the lumpiness gives you a positive move. Once the producers (run by in-tune, smart people) start to act a bit better, then you know the commodity will follow.
When Investors Like Dividends: Management Discipline
A company that pays a regular dividend has to have cash flow available for the payout, every single quarter. Knowing that investors are expecting a dividend, executives of the company have to show discipline. They cannot just randomly go on an expansion or acquisition spree without consideration of the cash flow requirements of that dividend, every three months. When an executive team looks at deals, they need to consider the long-term consequences. Any deal needs to be financed properly in order to make sure the current dividend can be paid. Any deal needs to be a good deal so that it does not impair the company’s dividend-paying ability in the future (and, preferably, allows the company to increase its dividend). Sure, non-dividend paying companies may have more capital available for growth, but this doesn’t mean the expected growth is going to pan out. We think this point is particularly valid at economic peaks, when confidence and stock valuations are high. We have seen many executives go on spending sprees at the exact wrong time (in hindsight). Companies paying dividends just seem to have more self control during ebullient times.
Unlock Premium - Try 5i Free
Earnings Growth and 2025
Warren Buffett was a student of Benjamin Graham, who wrote a seminal book on value investing. In the short run, the market is a voting machine. In the long run, it's a weighing machine. This means that in the short run, markets can get irrational, emotional, and swing up and down. In the long run, fundamentals matter and markets will track those long-term, fundamental trends.
To get a handle on short-term swings, Citigroup puts out the Economic Surprise Index. They compare the consensus for a particular economic indicator with the actual number, and whether it's a positive or negative surprise. Whether we're beating expectations or not tends to have an impact on markets.
When interest rates started to come down, the S&P 500 trend channel accelerated. Interest rates started to come down in 2024, until very recently where we're back at 5% again. Financial conditions are getting easier, which is what usually happens when interest rates fall and stocks do well.
But in the last couple of months, financial conditions have started to tighten. Both stocks and bonds are starting to work against the trend. If we start to see the 30-year break above 5% and hold, that spells to him tighter financial conditions and further weakness to come. What do we need to happen to get there?
Enter earnings season. In 2022, consensus expectations were for $260 of earnings for 2024. At the end of 2024, it now looks as though the number will be $242. The market typically, though not always, overestimates what earnings are going to be.
The consensus for 2025 is $272, which is more than 10% earnings growth. We're in a 4-5% nominal GDP market, so it would be difficult to generate that 10% growth unless things are firing on all cylinders. Looking at 2026, consensus is adding another 10% earnings growth on top of that. Markets are priced for perfection. Unless the news and outlook are both very, very good, expect people to sell into rallies during earnings season and expect financial conditions to tighten up a bit more.